Depp v Heard – Week 4, Day 14

Depp v Heard – Week 4, Day 14

82 tweets

Hi – welcome to fairfax county court virginia. I’ve had a UK TV commitment this morning so was unable to live tweet this morning. The first witness was nurse Erin Falati (née Boerum) being examined by JD’s attorney – she spoke to her notes about Amber Heard’s behaviour, drug…

… problems (self-reported), including cocaine. Her self-reported anxiety and feelings of jealousy and her difficult family background.
(If you missed it I’ll do a full report in my newsletter tonight: reportingdeppvheard.net/newsletter/
Nurse Erin was then taken through…

… specific events she witnessed with AH. Nurse Erin (NE) says she didn’t recall seeing any injuries in after she returned from Australia in March 2015.

There is more self-reporting from AH to NE about her trip to Coachella in April 2016 – admitted ingesting mushrooms and MDMA and getting sick…

NE says she never saw JD be violent towards AH, she never saw AH act violently towards JD, she only saw her lose her temper once. AH was never rude to her personally.

[NE is cross-examined again by AH attorney – she is shown pictures of alleged injuries sent to her by AH – agrees it is AH]

And there ends Nurse Erin’s evidence. Michael Spindler is called next. He is a aforesnic accountand giving evidence live in the courtroom.

[I am doing catch up tweeting on the morning’s events btw. If you want to watch this live, go here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8]

Spindler shows the court his research on how much money JD is alleged to have lost as a result of Amber Heard’s piece in the Washington Post in 2018 (the article is at the centre of this defamation trial).
Spindler estimates JD has lost $40.3m as a result of the article.

Under cross-examination Spindler admits that his estimates make the assumption that the article was what caused the loss of earnings. He is only estimating the damages based on what JD had taken away from him. Not why.

Also agrees that he did not see any written confirmation…

… that JD would have earned $22.5m for Pirates 6.

Also agrees his estimate on what he has lost from other films (the other $17.8m) was not on work taken away from him, but by comparing previous aggregate income.

[we also discover JD earned $70m in 2010 and not much less in 2011 – sheesh]

Also agrees that JD earned more money in 2020 than in 2018.

And that’s the end of Michael Spindler. Now comes the drama. After morning recess, with the jury out of court….

… AH’s team approach the court and ask the judge to make a summary ruling and dismiss the entire case.

The reasoning is that…

… Amber Heard’s 2018 op-ed was true. She did "become a public figures representing domestic abuse" in 2016 and that was because she sought and got a temporary restraining order (TRO) against Johnny Depp.

AH’s attorney, Ben Rottenborn, told the judge…

.. that multiple witnesses, including JD, had testified that domestic abuse does not have to be violent – it can be psychological and verbal. Apparently in California (where the TRO was secured) damage of objects (JD’s cupboard smashing and throwing AH’s clothes rail…

… down the stairs) could qualify as an act of abuse.

BR told the judge that all this evidence had come from JD’s witnesses.

His next point was that the “Sexual Violence” part of the WaPo op-ed was not written by AH and therefore she is not responsible for it.

The judge has some technical pushback on that but the evidential argument against is made by JD’s attorney Ben Chew who says AH tweeted the WaPo article and that tweet was the entirety of the headline.

Thirdly BR says that malice has not been proved.

Ben Chew takes over to say that the evidence so far has shown that AH is the abuser, and that the jury should be the final arbiter of this case.

BC says that under Virginia law, an article can be defamatory by inference or implication and that AH was directly responsible…

… for what she wrote.

BC makes the argument about AH: “No one was interested in what she had to say unless she was defaming Mr Depp"

BC calls the ex parte TRO “bogus” and a “scam” designed to screw $7m out of JD as a divorce settlement which she didn’t then give to the charities she said she would.

BC now listing evidence from police officers and nurses, and JD’s friends and employees all saying they saw no injuries.

Far from being a victim, says BC, AH is a:

“recidivist perpetrator of domestic violence on Mr Depp and others."

Then starts listing the occasions on which AH is alleged to have abused JD.

Says because the defamation is so strong, Mr Depp does not have to prove damages. But says he has done so anyway and that he has lost a lot.

Judge refuses to strike the trial on grounds two and three because the case is not made. On ground one she is going to take advice, but is not going to strike the trial now because to do so would be premature.

I think that is a technicality which is going to go away and would require another hearing anyway. So we’re back on and into the afternoon session.

I am about an hour behind tweeting on catch-up. If you want to watch the trial live, it’s here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8

Incidentally if you want to see my interview with @jessecordweber from the Law and Crime Netword on my latest youtube update about this case, you can find it here:

reportingdeppvheard.net/youtube/

Right – back to court for the first Amber Heard witness. She is Dr Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist from NYC.

Last Monday Dr Shannon Curry was a devastating witness for JD. She too was a forensic psychologist and she diagnosed AH with Borderline Personality Disorder and Histrionic Personality Disorder. She also said her claims of PTSD brought on by JD’s abuse were bogus.

We will see what Dr Hughes has to say of her assessment of AH.

Like many of the expert witnesses in this case, she is listing her qualifications and expertise at length. Like Dr Curry she comes across as highly qualified, experienced and competent.

She specialises in interpersonal violence and traumatic stress.

She is Board Certified, which Dr Shannon Curry was not.

She has trained Supreme Court justices on interpersonal violence.

She “frequently” finds people she examines are not suffering from interpersonal violence (IPV) or PTSD.

She is accepted by the court as an expert.

She says she is going to switch between IPV and domestic violence DV as terms which she says for the purposes of this case essentially mean the same things “a pattern of manipulation fear and coercive control… within an intimate relationship.”

It can involve…

“a variety of abusive behaviours… physical violence, sexual violence, psychological aggression, emotional abuse, stalking or surveillance behaviours and economic abuse”
These behaviours occur over time and not all at once and they can be interpersed with loving periods which…

… makes it "difficult for the victim to extricate herself".

DH is asked about digital penetration of the vagina as sexual abuse and whether an object penetrating the vagina is sexual abuse. DH says if it is non-consensual it is abuse.

DH is fluent – and like Shannon Curry speaking in simple clear terms to the jury. She is explaining all the definitions of DV she gave in the tweets above.

Now explaining why abused partners don’t leave their abusers and what that does to them (cause more damage, basically).

How victims feel shame after being abused and that, over time, that decreased their psychological function.

“The only person who can change the abuse is the abuser… the woman continues to think that she can fix it, and yet she can't, but she's the one who is then rendered helpless and hopeless because everything that she’s trying to do is failing."

“Women do report their use of violence” but says the majority is “reactive violence… self-defensive act violence… or sometimes violence that is perpetrated independently of an assault… but mostly that when the partner begins to become violent…

… then she may becomes violent and fight back, and that’s not an uncommon dynamic”

DH says you have to see if reactive violence can change the power dynamic in the relationship.

DH has throughout been using the words “she" and “her" as generic for a victim…

… of abuse, but then says:

“We have to be careful of gendered sterotypes, we can’t go in and think ‘oh – only the woman is the victim and only the man is the perpetrator – that just does not comport with the research. We know that the research shows we can have…

… domestic violence in same-sex relationships."

However she says in heterosexual relationships:

“Men still perpetrate more severe acts of violence, women are still more likely to be injured, they are much more likely to suffer sexual violence at the hands of their partner, they’re much more…

[sorry remove the last ‘much’ from the last tweet]

… likely to be intimidated, afraid and they’re much more likely to be killed” but “either one can be a perpetrator or a victim."

DH says her method is to look for coercive control in a relationship.

Is there sexual violence, is there intimidation and fear?

[just a note to remind you that I a merely summarising and paraphrasing what is being said in court – nothing is a direct quote unless it…

… is in “direct quotes”]

DH “Alcohol can just throw lighter fluid on a flame in a situation of domestic violence."

responses to DV:

1. Formal response, going to the authorities

2. Informal response: talking to mom or friends

3. Talking to partner, trying to change, adapt and cope.

1 is uncommon. Even when police are called it is common for victim not to cooperate.

DH is asked why do women stay in violent relationships

– they stay for the loving man the man who is kind. Economic reasons. Children in common. Retaliation – if I leave I’m going to get seriously hurt and the stastics bear this out [AH appears to nod at this point]

… the most dangerous time for a woman is when she’s trying to leave a relationship – her likelihood of being killed in that moment grows substantially. So it is safer for her to stay.

DH says destroying property is a risk factor for danger and fatality.

[we hit the afternoon recess. just a reminder that I am tweeting about half an hour behind proceedings on catch up – if you want to watch the remainder of today live it’s here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8]

[we are back]
DH says she conducted a forensic psychological evaluation of AH.
Says it has a clinical interview element, a testing component, to gather broad data and to look at defensiveness, malingering, exaggeration…

… documents are reviewed, medical records etc and collateral interviews. Does not assume everything/anything subject says is true.

Evalution followed standard methodology. Met with AH for 29 hours over four visits.

Breaks it down 4 x in NY for 21.5 hours and then over Zoom for 3 hrs and 4 hours over Zoom.

Testing, interview, three collateral interviews with two of her treating doctors and one with her mum.

Also looked at the docs in this case.

Conclusions are that “Ms Heard’s report of intimate partner violence and the records that I reviewed is consistent with what we know in the field about intimate partner violence, characterised by physical violence, psychological…

… aggression, sexual violence, coercive control and surveillance behaviours.”

DH’s second main opinion was that AH “demonstrated very clear psychological and traumatic effects or the exacerbation of trauma from those statements that Mr Depp made through his attorney…

… there were three statements that we evaluated to see how they affected her and it was my determination that they did.”

Her diagnostic conclusion?

“I diagnosed Ms Heard with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder… and the cause was the intimate partner violence by Mr Depp."

[ah so a confident declaration of almost the exact opposite of the diagnosis made by Dr Shannon Curry of the same person.

Incidentally I am not the only person thinking of Shannon Curry – Elaine Bredehoft just called Dr Hughes “Dr Curry”, much to DrH's evident distaste…

… and explained it by saying: “I think it’s the confusion of having her in the courtroom.”]

DrH has explained her methodology again and is using notes. This causes some confusion as there appears to be rules around expert witnesses reading from notes or their own reports.

She is allowed to refer to notes but not read from them. Though even that seems to cause an objection.

She is referring to notes about her interviews with Paige Heard and her consulting doctors.

She lists the 12 psychological tests she administered to AH, but she is not allowed to read them out as then it becomes hearsay or something.

DrH is clearly getting frustrated saying she doesn’t want this to turn into a “memory test”, but rules are rules.

DrH also tested for malingering, exaggeration and feigning. She did not have any signs. She is asked how Shannon Curry scored AH as being in the 98the percentile…

.. for exaggertion. DrH says the test should not use a percentile rank as it is normed on people with trauma and doesn’t work as a normal percentile range and it says not to do this in the test.

Describes DrC’s conclusion as “very inaccurate”.

[Who to believe, eh? The forensic psychologist hired by AH whose diagnosis is exactly the diagnosis that AH wanted, or the forensic psychologist hired by JD who got exactly the diagnosis that JD wanted?]

[DrH goes into a lengthy explanation of how AH’s childhood traumas of being abused at the hands of her violent father and coping with her parents substance abuse shaped her behaviours in her relationship with JD. DrH also being given ample opporunity to take potshots at and…

… pick holes in Dr Curry’s diagnoses and conclusions]

DrH, unsurprisingly, did not diagnose AH with BPD or HPD.

Says AH told her JD pushed, shoved, slapped, choked, and slammed her into a wall, pushed her so she fell down, kicked her in the back and suffered bruising, pain, cuts, vaginal pain from some of the sexual assaults, scratching from broken glass and losing consciousnnes.

Also suffered coercive control – her career, didn’t want her to show nudity, not act with certain actors because of obssessive jealousy, criticised her ambition, he’d rather she not work. It made her very fearful – didn’t want to talk about work or scripts. He called…

… every actor male or female and call the director that she worked with to make her aware he was watching had “eyes” down there…

DrH begins to report the sexual violence reported to her by AH and in Dr Bonnie Jacobs notes. Forced sex, whilst drunk or high. Forced oral sex when angry. Go to hicksville incident – DrH says JD performed “a cavity search” on AH saying he was looking for drugs…

“felt it acceptable to rip off her nightgown and stick his fingers up her vagina to look for cocaine… these incidents often happen in a drug-fuelled rage"

DrH goes into the methodology – how she came to these conclusions.

DrH says AH reported shouting, yelling at him, putting him down, pushing, shoving and hitting him. The punch was out of a fear for her sister’s safety.

DrH says she had to evaluate whether or not this made her an abuser, and DrH says she had to look at this in context.

DrH talking at length about AH’s other doctors and their conclusions about violence in the relationship.

Says that the majority of the violence and sexual violence was in the middle of alcohol and drug-fuelled rages, but when JD was not incapacitated he still displayed coercive control and jealousy.

[We’re getting very close to the end of the day. I’ll try to get a full report up as soon as possible after proceedings conclude – if you’d like to read it…

… please make a small one-off (one-time-only) donation here and you’ll be on board for the rest of the trial:

reportingdeppvheard.net/newsletter/

Thanks]


Hi – welcome to fairfax county court virginia. I’ve had a UK TV commitment this morning so was unable to live tweet this morning. The first witness was nurse Erin Falati (née Boerum) being examined by JD’s attorney – she spoke to her notes about Amber Heard’s behaviour, drug… … problems (self-reported), including cocaine. Her self-reported anxiety and feelings of jealousy and her difficult family background. (If you missed it I’ll do a full report in my newsletter tonight: https://reportingdeppvheard.net/newsletter/) Nurse Erin was then taken through… … specific events she witnessed with AH. Nurse Erin (NE) says she didn’t recall seeing any injuries in after she returned from Australia in March 2015. There is more self-reporting from AH to NE about her trip to Coachella in April 2016 – admitted ingesting mushrooms and MDMA and getting sick… NE says she never saw JD be violent towards AH, she never saw AH act violently towards JD, she only saw her lose her temper once. AH was never rude to her personally. [NE is cross-examined again by AH attorney – she is shown pictures of alleged injuries sent to her by AH – agrees it is AH] And there ends Nurse Erin’s evidence. Michael Spindler is called next. He is a aforesnic accountand giving evidence live in the courtroom. [I am doing catch up tweeting on the morning’s events btw. If you want to watch this live, go here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8] Spindler shows the court his research on how much money JD is alleged to have lost as a result of Amber Heard’s piece in the Washington Post in 2018 (the article is at the centre of this defamation trial). Spindler estimates JD has lost $40.3m as a result of the article. Under cross-examination Spindler admits that his estimates make the assumption that the article was what caused the loss of earnings. He is only estimating the damages based on what JD had taken away from him. Not why. Also agrees that he did not see any written confirmation… … that JD would have earned $22.5m for Pirates 6. Also agrees his estimate on what he has lost from other films (the other $17.8m) was not on work taken away from him, but by comparing previous aggregate income. [we also discover JD earned $70m in 2010 and not much less in 2011 – sheesh] Also agrees that JD earned more money in 2020 than in 2018. And that’s the end of Michael Spindler. Now comes the drama. After morning recess, with the jury out of court…. … AH’s team approach the court and ask the judge to make a summary ruling and dismiss the entire case. The reasoning is that… … Amber Heard’s 2018 op-ed was true. She did “become a public figures representing domestic abuse” in 2016 and that was because she sought and got a temporary restraining order (TRO) against Johnny Depp. AH’s attorney, Ben Rottenborn, told the judge… .. that multiple witnesses, including JD, had testified that domestic abuse does not have to be violent – it can be psychological and verbal. Apparently in California (where the TRO was secured) damage of objects (JD’s cupboard smashing and throwing AH’s clothes rail… … down the stairs) could qualify as an act of abuse. BR told the judge that all this evidence had come from JD’s witnesses. His next point was that the “Sexual Violence” part of the WaPo op-ed was not written by AH and therefore she is not responsible for it. The judge has some technical pushback on that but the evidential argument against is made by JD’s attorney Ben Chew who says AH tweeted the WaPo article and that tweet was the entirety of the headline. Thirdly BR says that malice has not been proved. Ben Chew takes over to say that the evidence so far has shown that AH is the abuser, and that the jury should be the final arbiter of this case. BC says that under Virginia law, an article can be defamatory by inference or implication and that AH was directly responsible… … for what she wrote. BC makes the argument about AH: “No one was interested in what she had to say unless she was defaming Mr Depp” BC calls the ex parte TRO “bogus” and a “scam” designed to screw $7m out of JD as a divorce settlement which she didn’t then give to the charities she said she would. BC now listing evidence from police officers and nurses, and JD’s friends and employees all saying they saw no injuries. Far from being a victim, says BC, AH is a: “recidivist perpetrator of domestic violence on Mr Depp and others.” Then starts listing the occasions on which AH is alleged to have abused JD. Says because the defamation is so strong, Mr Depp does not have to prove damages. But says he has done so anyway and that he has lost a lot. Judge refuses to strike the trial on grounds two and three because the case is not made. On ground one she is going to take advice, but is not going to strike the trial now because to do so would be premature. I think that is a technicality which is going to go away and would require another hearing anyway. So we’re back on and into the afternoon session. I am about an hour behind tweeting on catch-up. If you want to watch the trial live, it’s here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8 Incidentally if you want to see my interview with @jessecordweber from the Law and Crime Netword on my latest youtube update about this case, you can find it here:
YouTube
Right – back to court for the first Amber Heard witness. She is Dr Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist from NYC. Last Monday Dr Shannon Curry was a devastating witness for JD. She too was a forensic psychologist and she diagnosed AH with Borderline Personality Disorder and Histrionic Personality Disorder. She also said her claims of PTSD brought on by JD’s abuse were bogus. We will see what Dr Hughes has to say of her assessment of AH. Like many of the expert witnesses in this case, she is listing her qualifications and expertise at length. Like Dr Curry she comes across as highly qualified, experienced and competent. She specialises in interpersonal violence and traumatic stress. She is Board Certified, which Dr Shannon Curry was not. She has trained Supreme Court justices on interpersonal violence. She “frequently” finds people she examines are not suffering from interpersonal violence (IPV) or PTSD. She is accepted by the court as an expert. She says she is going to switch between IPV and domestic violence DV as terms which she says for the purposes of this case essentially mean the same things “a pattern of manipulation fear and coercive control… within an intimate relationship.” It can involve… “a variety of abusive behaviours… physical violence, sexual violence, psychological aggression, emotional abuse, stalking or surveillance behaviours and economic abuse” These behaviours occur over time and not all at once and they can be interpersed with loving periods which… … makes it “difficult for the victim to extricate herself”. DH is asked about digital penetration of the vagina as sexual abuse and whether an object penetrating the vagina is sexual abuse. DH says if it is non-consensual it is abuse. DH is fluent – and like Shannon Curry speaking in simple clear terms to the jury. She is explaining all the definitions of DV she gave in the tweets above. Now explaining why abused partners don’t leave their abusers and what that does to them (cause more damage, basically). How victims feel shame after being abused and that, over time, that decreased their psychological function. “The only person who can change the abuse is the abuser… the woman continues to think that she can fix it, and yet she can’t, but she’s the one who is then rendered helpless and hopeless because everything that she’s trying to do is failing.” “Women do report their use of violence” but says the majority is “reactive violence… self-defensive act violence… or sometimes violence that is perpetrated independently of an assault… but mostly that when the partner begins to become violent… … then she may becomes violent and fight back, and that’s not an uncommon dynamic” DH says you have to see if reactive violence can change the power dynamic in the relationship. DH has throughout been using the words “she” and “her” as generic for a victim… … of abuse, but then says: “We have to be careful of gendered sterotypes, we can’t go in and think ‘oh – only the woman is the victim and only the man is the perpetrator – that just does not comport with the research. We know that the research shows we can have… … domestic violence in same-sex relationships.” However she says in heterosexual relationships: “Men still perpetrate more severe acts of violence, women are still more likely to be injured, they are much more likely to suffer sexual violence at the hands of their partner, they’re much more… [sorry remove the last ‘much’ from the last tweet] … likely to be intimidated, afraid and they’re much more likely to be killed” but “either one can be a perpetrator or a victim.” DH says her method is to look for coercive control in a relationship. Is there sexual violence, is there intimidation and fear? [just a note to remind you that I a merely summarising and paraphrasing what is being said in court – nothing is a direct quote unless it… … is in “direct quotes”] DH “Alcohol can just throw lighter fluid on a flame in a situation of domestic violence.” responses to DV: 1. Formal response, going to the authorities 2. Informal response: talking to mom or friends 3. Talking to partner, trying to change, adapt and cope. 1 is uncommon. Even when police are called it is common for victim not to cooperate. DH is asked why do women stay in violent relationships – they stay for the loving man the man who is kind. Economic reasons. Children in common. Retaliation – if I leave I’m going to get seriously hurt and the stastics bear this out [AH appears to nod at this point] … the most dangerous time for a woman is when she’s trying to leave a relationship – her likelihood of being killed in that moment grows substantially. So it is safer for her to stay. DH says destroying property is a risk factor for danger and fatality. [we hit the afternoon recess. just a reminder that I am tweeting about half an hour behind proceedings on catch up – if you want to watch the remainder of today live it’s here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCkYAh1my8] [we are back] DH says she conducted a forensic psychological evaluation of AH. Says it has a clinical interview element, a testing component, to gather broad data and to look at defensiveness, malingering, exaggeration… … documents are reviewed, medical records etc and collateral interviews. Does not assume everything/anything subject says is true. Evalution followed standard methodology. Met with AH for 29 hours over four visits. Breaks it down 4 x in NY for 21.5 hours and then over Zoom for 3 hrs and 4 hours over Zoom. Testing, interview, three collateral interviews with two of her treating doctors and one with her mum. Also looked at the docs in this case. Conclusions are that “Ms Heard’s report of intimate partner violence and the records that I reviewed is consistent with what we know in the field about intimate partner violence, characterised by physical violence, psychological… … aggression, sexual violence, coercive control and surveillance behaviours.” DH’s second main opinion was that AH “demonstrated very clear psychological and traumatic effects or the exacerbation of trauma from those statements that Mr Depp made through his attorney… … there were three statements that we evaluated to see how they affected her and it was my determination that they did.” Her diagnostic conclusion? “I diagnosed Ms Heard with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder… and the cause was the intimate partner violence by Mr Depp.” [ah so a confident declaration of almost the exact opposite of the diagnosis made by Dr Shannon Curry of the same person. Incidentally I am not the only person thinking of Shannon Curry – Elaine Bredehoft just called Dr Hughes “Dr Curry”, much to DrH’s evident distaste… … and explained it by saying: “I think it’s the confusion of having her in the courtroom.”] DrH has explained her methodology again and is using notes. This causes some confusion as there appears to be rules around expert witnesses reading from notes or their own reports. She is allowed to refer to notes but not read from them. Though even that seems to cause an objection. She is referring to notes about her interviews with Paige Heard and her consulting doctors. She lists the 12 psychological tests she administered to AH, but she is not allowed to read them out as then it becomes hearsay or something. DrH is clearly getting frustrated saying she doesn’t want this to turn into a “memory test”, but rules are rules. DrH also tested for malingering, exaggeration and feigning. She did not have any signs. She is asked how Shannon Curry scored AH as being in the 98the percentile… .. for exaggertion. DrH says the test should not use a percentile rank as it is normed on people with trauma and doesn’t work as a normal percentile range and it says not to do this in the test. Describes DrC’s conclusion as “very inaccurate”. [Who to believe, eh? The forensic psychologist hired by AH whose diagnosis is exactly the diagnosis that AH wanted, or the forensic psychologist hired by JD who got exactly the diagnosis that JD wanted?] [DrH goes into a lengthy explanation of how AH’s childhood traumas of being abused at the hands of her violent father and coping with her parents substance abuse shaped her behaviours in her relationship with JD. DrH also being given ample opporunity to take potshots at and… … pick holes in Dr Curry’s diagnoses and conclusions] DrH, unsurprisingly, did not diagnose AH with BPD or HPD. Says AH told her JD pushed, shoved, slapped, choked, and slammed her into a wall, pushed her so she fell down, kicked her in the back and suffered bruising, pain, cuts, vaginal pain from some of the sexual assaults, scratching from broken glass and losing consciousnnes. Also suffered coercive control – her career, didn’t want her to show nudity, not act with certain actors because of obssessive jealousy, criticised her ambition, he’d rather she not work. It made her very fearful – didn’t want to talk about work or scripts. He called… … every actor male or female and call the director that she worked with to make her aware he was watching had “eyes” down there… DrH begins to report the sexual violence reported to her by AH and in Dr Bonnie Jacobs notes. Forced sex, whilst drunk or high. Forced oral sex when angry. Go to hicksville incident – DrH says JD performed “a cavity search” on AH saying he was looking for drugs… “felt it acceptable to rip off her nightgown and stick his fingers up her vagina to look for cocaine… these incidents often happen in a drug-fuelled rage” DrH goes into the methodology – how she came to these conclusions. DrH says AH reported shouting, yelling at him, putting him down, pushing, shoving and hitting him. The punch was out of a fear for her sister’s safety. DrH says she had to evaluate whether or not this made her an abuser, and DrH says she had to look at this in context. DrH talking at length about AH’s other doctors and their conclusions about violence in the relationship. Says that the majority of the violence and sexual violence was in the middle of alcohol and drug-fuelled rages, but when JD was not incapacitated he still displayed coercive control and jealousy. [We’re getting very close to the end of the day. I’ll try to get a full report up as soon as possible after proceedings conclude – if you’d like to read it… … please make a small one-off (one-time-only) donation here and you’ll be on board for the rest of the trial:
Newsletter
Thanks]