Depp v Heard Day 4 part 1

Depp v Heard Day 4 part 1

62 tweets

Apologies for the late start to “live”-tweeting proceedings this morning. We started with evidence by video deposition from Stone Cold Kate Jones, Amber Heard’s personal assistant who radiated contempt for whichever poor attorney was cross-examining her. And radiated contempt…

… Amber Heard. Ms James was the witness in the 2020 trial who gave live-evidence by video link. During that evidence she was clearly angry about her former employer, stating: "Ms. Heard referred to a conversation we had about me being violently raped at…

… machete-point in Brazil and she used it as her own story. She referred directly to a violent rape that occurred to me 26 years ago and she twisted it into her own story and she used it for her own use.”

Earlier she had said "I’m a sexual violence survivor and…

… that’s very, very serious to take that stance if you are not one and I am one. That’s the reason I’m here, because I take offence.”

[error correction sorry – she is called Kate James]

Today she explained her job for AH as a personal assistant, initially describing…

… her duties as “too many to mention” and then, after the polite entreaties from the attorney she launched into a long list which included going shopping, running errands, picking up flowers, getting the dogs groomed, liaising with people on movie sets, sorting travel…

She was asked “And you were paid for that work, correct?”
“Very poorly.” was the response.
What – like $1500 a week?
KJ laughed and said “I wish. My God.” adding that AH finally agreed, "after screaming abuse" to pay her $50,000 a year.

She described this as “very insulting” but she agreed to do it as she had “grandfathered in” the ability to pick up her son from school at 3pm every day.
KJ I have always lived in LA since 1999
Attorney (A) – and you didn’t travel with her when she was out of town
KJ that was…

… another part of her agreement.
A and she travelled a lot
KJ we’re talking about ten yrs ago so I couldn’t really tell you
A how often did you see JD
KJ “regularly”
A weekly, daily?
KJ “there is no rhyme or reason to answer that question”
agrees she never witnessed…

… any violence between JD and AH
when asked about arguments, she says she’d get occasional texts “complaining about her mental state”
A brings up the flight from Boston to LA. Asks what she may have heard about that flight.
“Don’t know.”
A you don’t remember?
KJ “I don’t know…

… I wasn’t on the plane. I just know what happened afterwards, okay? when she asked to come and meet her at the Chateau”
A did you ask her if she was okay
KJ I probbably did because that’s my role, to play a care-giver.
A what do you remember about this day
KJ mostly my surprise

… that they went to the Chateau Marmont because she had an apartment of her own in West Hollywood that was completely and available to her – that was my biggest confusion – like why did she go to the Chateau, and then she asked me to get her bathing suit. I remember that…

… so I had to go to her apt to get her bathing soon which again seems strange to me and then when I got there she had a bunch of friends with her. Originally I thought she was alone.
A you mean the apt on Orange Ave
KJ yes
A JD would spend time there with AH
KJ I don’t know…

.., what you’re getting at but he wasn’t there at that time.
A but he spent time at that apt
KJ yes there and other residences
A were you concerned about AH
KJ no becaus it had become a pattern with her because I was merely placating her, especially when I saw her with…

… four of five girlfriends basically having fun, enjoying each other down by the pool. That’s why she needed a swimsuit and they proceeded to hang there all day basically drinking while I sat around waiting with my son. It was a Sunday. We had to wait all day whilst they…

… basically hung around drinking by the pool and then finally I went home and she went back to her apt and then she wanted to pack her bags at 10pm that night and I said couldn’t go as I’d already spent the whole day sitting there and so I said I couldn’t go and pack her…

… bag as I’d already put my son to bed and she was very angry about that.
A when you asked if she was okay you didn’t care if she was okay.
KJ it was standard procedure. I was merely placating her. She was a very dramatic person.
A you didn’t think AH was upset
KJ it didn’t…

… make sense that she would go to the Chateau instead of going home. That was the first red flag to me that day.
A you thought she wasn’t upst
KJ “this is too much. I mean, I’ve already answered once.”
A “what I”m asking is did you come to the conclusion there is nothing…

… wrong with Ms Heard that day. She wasn’t actually upset.”
KJ “I don’t know how to answer. It’s such a strange question. [Pause] Like I said – you already asked me and I already answered.”
A “I’m asking you to answer again. I don’t think I asked the exact same question."

KJ [by now broiling with contempt] “Could you ask me the question in a different way, or a clearer way that is not exactly the same as the last question you asked me?”
A “Did you reach the conclusion that day that Ms Heard had not experienced anything traumatic?”
KJ “Over the…

… course of the day I observed Ms Heard enjoying the company of her friends for several hours. That’s all I have to say on that matter.”
A "would it be odd for someone who’s experienced trauma to be around friends?"
KJ “I don’t know.”
A “You say you sat around at the Chateau…

… Marmont, is that right?”
KJ “Yes, whilst she was deciding what to do.”
A “Now you were being paid for that time, correct?”
KJ “Not overtime. It was a Sunday. I was not being paid, no.”
A “Did you, um, avail yourself of anything at the hotel, like did you order any food?"

KJ “No. I might have ordered some food for my son to be honest now I think about it because he was only 5 or something so I might have ordered food for my son. I’m not a big eater. Food is not a … priorty for me.”
A “would you have put that on Ms Heard’s tab that day?"

KJ “Everything was on Depp’s tab that day. So, no.”

….

When asked when she knew that things were not well between AH and JD, KJ says she remembers her "complaining and crying due to, I would say, insecurities in the relationship…

… more than anything else. She would be very very insecure a lot of the time and she would call me up crying.”

KJ reiterates she never saw any JD mistreating AH. “I was there at the time. Almost daily. Both her place and then eventually his place in West Hollywood…

… and then ultimately at the lofts (the ECB) downtown. It was a daily basis experience. Morning, noon, night. All days of the week. So I never once saw any evidence of anything.”

…

A you never believed Ah that JD had mistreated her?
KJ at the time or after?

A during
KJ no, never. Never any damage to the apt that I witnessed. Never any witness to anything ever that i ever saw

A you have n knowledge whether JD was abusive to her, correct?
KJ “I don’t know if that’s necessarily true, because if it was true… I would have seen…

… the damage. Even if I wasn’t physically present in the moment in the moment of these alleged arguments.”
A what’s your basis for that statement?
KJ If someone’s been beaten, there’s generally physical evidence.
A so your evidence is if there’s no physical evidence…

…. that you observed then it couldn’t have happened. is that your testimony?
KJ no.
A what is your testimony? Is it that if you never saw first hand evidence of JD being violent towards AH then it couldn’t have happened.
KJ “that’s not what I said. You’re trying to put…

… words into my mouth. I don’t appreciate that."

KJ now being asked about a meeting with JD when he suggested they meet up “to fix her flabby ass”
A was this about AH
KJ not clear. he writes in a very abstract way
A it was about AH. Your earlier testimony in the UK says it was.
KJ no. I was just trying to be agreeable…

… in the court having no clue what was going on. So – there you go.
A was that answer in the court truthful or agreeable
KJ agreeable
A so it wasn’t truthful?
KJ I don’t have an answer Mr Rottenborn
A what did you talk about that meeting
KJ I don’t recall details

A anything
KJ it’s too long ago Mr Rottenborn. I don’t recall
A anything?
KJ No

A manages to establish AH was part of the conversation.
A Anything else?
KJ no
KJ says she has not seen JD since that conversation (which I think was in 2016)

[we move on to JD’s drug use]

A did you see JD using illegal drugs
KJ no
A abuse alcohol
KJ no
A did you ever speak with Dr Kipper
KJ No
A Erin Borem [?]
KJ yes. she was assigned to AH that’s how I came to know her.

A any concerns in your own mind about JD’s behaviour to AH?
KJ never
A nothing ever?
KJ never
A your employment with AH ended in 2015. Did AH terminate your employment?
KJ [in short] yes
A did you resent AH
KJ it would have been nice to have been given some notice so I had…

… some time to look around but apart from the lack of notice no I was not upset
A you got six weeks severance?
KJ I do not recall
A you wanted to stay in the job?
KJ I asked for a few months heads up so I could seek another job but she did not allow that
A and that made…

… you angry, correect?
KJ no…
A did you ask to be put on JD’s pay roll
KJ I did but she said I couldn’t because of a legal agreement she had
A didn’t you ask JD to go on his payroll
KJ no
A you asked to live in one of his houses rent free
[jump cuts]
KJ well you see I’m a…

[apologies for the break in live tweeting. I witnessed a young woman apparently being ejected from court by three deputy sheriffs. She had a discussion with less than 10 yards away which became a disagreement. She was then led away. This apparently happened to a JD fan…

… yesterday. Trying to find out more from the Court Information Officer. There are very strict rules about what you can and can’t do in court which we are regularly warned about, however one friend of the young woman ejected yesterday said it had nothing to do with her…

… behaviour or actions in court]

Dammit – now torn between going back and doing the rest of KJ’s testimony or catching up with the next witness Lauren Anderson. I think we’ll go with the latter, as we know where it was going with KJ.

Okay forgive me sorry – the law and crime live youtube feed is here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=76zbzPnnYcI

And please – I forgot to say earlier – nothing I tweet is a verbatim quote unless it is in “verbatim quote marks”. the rest is summary and paraphrase.

Laurel Anderson is on the stand…

She is an LA clinical psychologist.

She provides psychotherapy for indivduals and couples. Evaluation of problems and conceptualisation, then intervention that leads to change.

Did a couples session first for AH and JD on 1 Oct 2015, then
6 Oct 2015 solo session for AH
7 Oct 2015 solo session for JD

then goes on to list various couples and solo sessions – all lasted more than an hour. Some 3hrs+

LA is being shown an email from Christian Carino which sets up the counselling meetings. The email suggests the initiative has come from AH.

LA is being taken to more emails. She says she thought JD was “having difficulty in the sessions and I think there was something about the process between the two of them that I was trying to clue them into.”
A what difficulty was JD having
LA “having a voice”
A what do you mean?

LA Ms Heard had a jackhammer style of talking. She was very amped up. He could not talk at a similar pace – he was cut off a lot. He didn’t have a voice. He was really overwhelmed.
A in working with AH and JD did AH report any physical violence?
LA yes
A did you see photos?

LA yes
A what do you recall about the photos
LA her face was bruised.
A where on her face?
LA around her eyes
A did you witness any abuse
LA no
A had you worked with JD before?
LA no
A do you think there was violence from JD towards AH
LA yes you’re right. He had been…

… well controlled I think for almost 20-30 years and both were victims of abuse in their homes, but I thought he had been well-controlled for decades and with AH he was triggered and they engaged in what I saw as mutual abuse.

"Sometimes… I know she led on more than one occasion and started it to keep him with her because abondonment and having him leave was her worst nightmare and I think he may have initiated it on occasions too. That, I am less sure of.”
A how did you come to conclude AH abused…

… Mr Depp?
LA “Ms Heard reported that.”
A what did she report
LA “Two things. It was a point of pride to her if she felt disrespected to initiate a fight. Her father had beaten her. She was not…” [cut] “and the second was what she reported to me which was if he was…

…

[we go to a session on 13 Jan 2016]
A joint or solo session?

LA in person with AH solo

A you write “didn’t fight on island until last day. on island started to get into something.” what were you referring to there?

LA well xmas had occurred and the goal was to try to…

… get through the holiday without fighting and she was reporting on that.
A you write “he got aggressive, threatening, didn’t touch him, hid in bathroom” what were you referring to there?
LA what she reported to me which was that she didn’t participate.
A then you…

… write “she threw can at him… fighting” who is who
LA AH and JD
[we go to an email written by LA on 8 March 2016.]
A you weren’t enthusiastic about the idea of making a housecall
LA I was not

[we go to 16 June 2016 – a solo JD session with LA]

LA you write “fight on her…

her 22 April birthday. Huge fight. His mother died on the 20th” could you please describe that for the record?
[sorry that was A, not LA]

LA This is when I was phoned at home which was new. DV charges had been made, his mother had just died…

A when he told you there was a…

… fight was that AH’s 30th birthday. Is he telling you he arrived late and there was a huge fight.
LA yep
A do you know who Tasha VR is?
LA yes know of her
A you write “was chaotic, violent, but gave as good as she got.” what does that mean.
LA I’m quote JD, but I’m just typing

… some of the words he was saying. He’s also very verbal when no one’s interrupting him. He was talking about how chaotic it was how violent it was and she gave as good as she got. That’s kind of a direct quote. That’s not my kind of language.

A You write “she reported trying to initiate a fight with him one night by slapping him when she was offended by what he said” – is that AH and JD
LA yep
A then “it was also at this time that she showed me photos of her injuries” when did AH show you photos of her alleged…

… injuries?
LA right after that fight. Came in the next day. Or later.
A photos or…
LA both. photos and in person
A what did she show you
LA bruising on her face. There may have been more but I don’t remember.

[another attorney takes over briefly]
A what was the size of the bruise on her face you observed on 17 Dec.
LA an inch under her eye in more than one place
A multiple bruises on AH’s face
LA yes
A bruises under AH’s eyes
LA that’s what I recall. They may have been on other…

… places throughout her body. I don’t recall. But I do remember her face.
…

[we take a break for lunch. please remember that unless I am writing in direct quotes I am summarising and paraphrasing. The live feed is here! www.youtube.com/watch?v=76zbzPnnYcI]

We’re about to restart I think with a new witness after lunch. I really want to be in court for a bit, which means no live tweeting. I will take notes and summarise when I come out, but forgive me for diving in. The live link in the last tweet is still up, doing its job. I’ll…

… come out in half an hour or so and pick up….


Apologies for the late start to “live”-tweeting proceedings this morning. We started with evidence by video deposition from Stone Cold Kate Jones, Amber Heard’s personal assistant who radiated contempt for whichever poor attorney was cross-examining her. And radiated contempt… … Amber Heard. Ms James was the witness in the 2020 trial who gave live-evidence by video link. During that evidence she was clearly angry about her former employer, stating: “Ms. Heard referred to a conversation we had about me being violently raped at… … machete-point in Brazil and she used it as her own story. She referred directly to a violent rape that occurred to me 26 years ago and she twisted it into her own story and she used it for her own use.” Earlier she had said “I’m a sexual violence survivor and… … that’s very, very serious to take that stance if you are not one and I am one. That’s the reason I’m here, because I take offence.” [error correction sorry – she is called Kate James] Today she explained her job for AH as a personal assistant, initially describing… … her duties as “too many to mention” and then, after the polite entreaties from the attorney she launched into a long list which included going shopping, running errands, picking up flowers, getting the dogs groomed, liaising with people on movie sets, sorting travel… She was asked “And you were paid for that work, correct?” “Very poorly.” was the response. What – like $1500 a week? KJ laughed and said “I wish. My God.” adding that AH finally agreed, “after screaming abuse” to pay her $50,000 a year. She described this as “very insulting” but she agreed to do it as she had “grandfathered in” the ability to pick up her son from school at 3pm every day. KJ I have always lived in LA since 1999 Attorney (A) – and you didn’t travel with her when she was out of town KJ that was… … another part of her agreement. A and she travelled a lot KJ we’re talking about ten yrs ago so I couldn’t really tell you A how often did you see JD KJ “regularly” A weekly, daily? KJ “there is no rhyme or reason to answer that question” agrees she never witnessed… … any violence between JD and AH when asked about arguments, she says she’d get occasional texts “complaining about her mental state” A brings up the flight from Boston to LA. Asks what she may have heard about that flight. “Don’t know.” A you don’t remember? KJ “I don’t know… … I wasn’t on the plane. I just know what happened afterwards, okay? when she asked to come and meet her at the Chateau” A did you ask her if she was okay KJ I probbably did because that’s my role, to play a care-giver. A what do you remember about this day KJ mostly my surprise … that they went to the Chateau Marmont because she had an apartment of her own in West Hollywood that was completely and available to her – that was my biggest confusion – like why did she go to the Chateau, and then she asked me to get her bathing suit. I remember that… … so I had to go to her apt to get her bathing soon which again seems strange to me and then when I got there she had a bunch of friends with her. Originally I thought she was alone. A you mean the apt on Orange Ave KJ yes A JD would spend time there with AH KJ I don’t know… .., what you’re getting at but he wasn’t there at that time. A but he spent time at that apt KJ yes there and other residences A were you concerned about AH KJ no becaus it had become a pattern with her because I was merely placating her, especially when I saw her with… … four of five girlfriends basically having fun, enjoying each other down by the pool. That’s why she needed a swimsuit and they proceeded to hang there all day basically drinking while I sat around waiting with my son. It was a Sunday. We had to wait all day whilst they… … basically hung around drinking by the pool and then finally I went home and she went back to her apt and then she wanted to pack her bags at 10pm that night and I said couldn’t go as I’d already spent the whole day sitting there and so I said I couldn’t go and pack her… … bag as I’d already put my son to bed and she was very angry about that. A when you asked if she was okay you didn’t care if she was okay. KJ it was standard procedure. I was merely placating her. She was a very dramatic person. A you didn’t think AH was upset KJ it didn’t… … make sense that she would go to the Chateau instead of going home. That was the first red flag to me that day. A you thought she wasn’t upst KJ “this is too much. I mean, I’ve already answered once.” A “what I”m asking is did you come to the conclusion there is nothing… … wrong with Ms Heard that day. She wasn’t actually upset.” KJ “I don’t know how to answer. It’s such a strange question. [Pause] Like I said – you already asked me and I already answered.” A “I’m asking you to answer again. I don’t think I asked the exact same question.” KJ [by now broiling with contempt] “Could you ask me the question in a different way, or a clearer way that is not exactly the same as the last question you asked me?” A “Did you reach the conclusion that day that Ms Heard had not experienced anything traumatic?” KJ “Over the… … course of the day I observed Ms Heard enjoying the company of her friends for several hours. That’s all I have to say on that matter.” A “would it be odd for someone who’s experienced trauma to be around friends?” KJ “I don’t know.” A “You say you sat around at the Chateau… … Marmont, is that right?” KJ “Yes, whilst she was deciding what to do.” A “Now you were being paid for that time, correct?” KJ “Not overtime. It was a Sunday. I was not being paid, no.” A “Did you, um, avail yourself of anything at the hotel, like did you order any food?” KJ “No. I might have ordered some food for my son to be honest now I think about it because he was only 5 or something so I might have ordered food for my son. I’m not a big eater. Food is not a … priorty for me.” A “would you have put that on Ms Heard’s tab that day?” KJ “Everything was on Depp’s tab that day. So, no.” …. When asked when she knew that things were not well between AH and JD, KJ says she remembers her “complaining and crying due to, I would say, insecurities in the relationship… … more than anything else. She would be very very insecure a lot of the time and she would call me up crying.” KJ reiterates she never saw any JD mistreating AH. “I was there at the time. Almost daily. Both her place and then eventually his place in West Hollywood… … and then ultimately at the lofts (the ECB) downtown. It was a daily basis experience. Morning, noon, night. All days of the week. So I never once saw any evidence of anything.” … A you never believed Ah that JD had mistreated her? KJ at the time or after? A during KJ no, never. Never any damage to the apt that I witnessed. Never any witness to anything ever that i ever saw A you have n knowledge whether JD was abusive to her, correct? KJ “I don’t know if that’s necessarily true, because if it was true… I would have seen… … the damage. Even if I wasn’t physically present in the moment in the moment of these alleged arguments.” A what’s your basis for that statement? KJ If someone’s been beaten, there’s generally physical evidence. A so your evidence is if there’s no physical evidence… …. that you observed then it couldn’t have happened. is that your testimony? KJ no. A what is your testimony? Is it that if you never saw first hand evidence of JD being violent towards AH then it couldn’t have happened. KJ “that’s not what I said. You’re trying to put… … words into my mouth. I don’t appreciate that.” KJ now being asked about a meeting with JD when he suggested they meet up “to fix her flabby ass” A was this about AH KJ not clear. he writes in a very abstract way A it was about AH. Your earlier testimony in the UK says it was. KJ no. I was just trying to be agreeable… … in the court having no clue what was going on. So – there you go. A was that answer in the court truthful or agreeable KJ agreeable A so it wasn’t truthful? KJ I don’t have an answer Mr Rottenborn A what did you talk about that meeting KJ I don’t recall details A anything KJ it’s too long ago Mr Rottenborn. I don’t recall A anything? KJ No A manages to establish AH was part of the conversation. A Anything else? KJ no KJ says she has not seen JD since that conversation (which I think was in 2016) [we move on to JD’s drug use] A did you see JD using illegal drugs KJ no A abuse alcohol KJ no A did you ever speak with Dr Kipper KJ No A Erin Borem [?] KJ yes. she was assigned to AH that’s how I came to know her. A any concerns in your own mind about JD’s behaviour to AH? KJ never A nothing ever? KJ never A your employment with AH ended in 2015. Did AH terminate your employment? KJ [in short] yes A did you resent AH KJ it would have been nice to have been given some notice so I had… … some time to look around but apart from the lack of notice no I was not upset A you got six weeks severance? KJ I do not recall A you wanted to stay in the job? KJ I asked for a few months heads up so I could seek another job but she did not allow that A and that made… … you angry, correect? KJ no… A did you ask to be put on JD’s pay roll KJ I did but she said I couldn’t because of a legal agreement she had A didn’t you ask JD to go on his payroll KJ no A you asked to live in one of his houses rent free [jump cuts] KJ well you see I’m a… [apologies for the break in live tweeting. I witnessed a young woman apparently being ejected from court by three deputy sheriffs. She had a discussion with less than 10 yards away which became a disagreement. She was then led away. This apparently happened to a JD fan… … yesterday. Trying to find out more from the Court Information Officer. There are very strict rules about what you can and can’t do in court which we are regularly warned about, however one friend of the young woman ejected yesterday said it had nothing to do with her… … behaviour or actions in court] Dammit – now torn between going back and doing the rest of KJ’s testimony or catching up with the next witness Lauren Anderson. I think we’ll go with the latter, as we know where it was going with KJ. Okay forgive me sorry – the law and crime live youtube feed is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76zbzPnnYcI And please – I forgot to say earlier – nothing I tweet is a verbatim quote unless it is in “verbatim quote marks”. the rest is summary and paraphrase. Laurel Anderson is on the stand… She is an LA clinical psychologist. She provides psychotherapy for indivduals and couples. Evaluation of problems and conceptualisation, then intervention that leads to change. Did a couples session first for AH and JD on 1 Oct 2015, then 6 Oct 2015 solo session for AH 7 Oct 2015 solo session for JD then goes on to list various couples and solo sessions – all lasted more than an hour. Some 3hrs+ LA is being shown an email from Christian Carino which sets up the counselling meetings. The email suggests the initiative has come from AH. LA is being taken to more emails. She says she thought JD was “having difficulty in the sessions and I think there was something about the process between the two of them that I was trying to clue them into.” A what difficulty was JD having LA “having a voice” A what do you mean? LA Ms Heard had a jackhammer style of talking. She was very amped up. He could not talk at a similar pace – he was cut off a lot. He didn’t have a voice. He was really overwhelmed. A in working with AH and JD did AH report any physical violence? LA yes A did you see photos? LA yes A what do you recall about the photos LA her face was bruised. A where on her face? LA around her eyes A did you witness any abuse LA no A had you worked with JD before? LA no A do you think there was violence from JD towards AH LA yes you’re right. He had been… … well controlled I think for almost 20-30 years and both were victims of abuse in their homes, but I thought he had been well-controlled for decades and with AH he was triggered and they engaged in what I saw as mutual abuse. “Sometimes… I know she led on more than one occasion and started it to keep him with her because abondonment and having him leave was her worst nightmare and I think he may have initiated it on occasions too. That, I am less sure of.” A how did you come to conclude AH abused… … Mr Depp? LA “Ms Heard reported that.” A what did she report LA “Two things. It was a point of pride to her if she felt disrespected to initiate a fight. Her father had beaten her. She was not…” [cut] “and the second was what she reported to me which was if he was… … [we go to a session on 13 Jan 2016] A joint or solo session? LA in person with AH solo A you write “didn’t fight on island until last day. on island started to get into something.” what were you referring to there? LA well xmas had occurred and the goal was to try to… … get through the holiday without fighting and she was reporting on that. A you write “he got aggressive, threatening, didn’t touch him, hid in bathroom” what were you referring to there? LA what she reported to me which was that she didn’t participate. A then you… … write “she threw can at him… fighting” who is who LA AH and JD [we go to an email written by LA on 8 March 2016.] A you weren’t enthusiastic about the idea of making a housecall LA I was not [we go to 16 June 2016 – a solo JD session with LA] LA you write “fight on her… her 22 April birthday. Huge fight. His mother died on the 20th” could you please describe that for the record? [sorry that was A, not LA] LA This is when I was phoned at home which was new. DV charges had been made, his mother had just died… A when he told you there was a… … fight was that AH’s 30th birthday. Is he telling you he arrived late and there was a huge fight. LA yep A do you know who Tasha VR is? LA yes know of her A you write “was chaotic, violent, but gave as good as she got.” what does that mean. LA I’m quote JD, but I’m just typing … some of the words he was saying. He’s also very verbal when no one’s interrupting him. He was talking about how chaotic it was how violent it was and she gave as good as she got. That’s kind of a direct quote. That’s not my kind of language. A You write “she reported trying to initiate a fight with him one night by slapping him when she was offended by what he said” – is that AH and JD LA yep A then “it was also at this time that she showed me photos of her injuries” when did AH show you photos of her alleged… … injuries? LA right after that fight. Came in the next day. Or later. A photos or… LA both. photos and in person A what did she show you LA bruising on her face. There may have been more but I don’t remember. [another attorney takes over briefly] A what was the size of the bruise on her face you observed on 17 Dec. LA an inch under her eye in more than one place A multiple bruises on AH’s face LA yes A bruises under AH’s eyes LA that’s what I recall. They may have been on other… … places throughout her body. I don’t recall. But I do remember her face. … [we take a break for lunch. please remember that unless I am writing in direct quotes I am summarising and paraphrasing. The live feed is here! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76zbzPnnYcI] We’re about to restart I think with a new witness after lunch. I really want to be in court for a bit, which means no live tweeting. I will take notes and summarise when I come out, but forgive me for diving in. The live link in the last tweet is still up, doing its job. I’ll… … come out in half an hour or so and pick up….